BNSF oil train derailment in 2013. Billionaire Warren Buffett has bet the future of his company Berkshire Hathaway on dirty energy. In recent years he has been building a vertically-integrated fossil fuel empire one that develops, delivers, processes, and burns the most climate-destroying fuels. The final part of this series on Buffett looks at how BNSF Railways is the engine of his carbon-intensive conglomerate, creating a massive risk for shareholders in this increasingly carbon-constrained world a risk the Oracle of Omaha needs to be far more upfront about.
Is Warren Buffett The Profiteer of Climate Killers ?
When Rolling Stone named Warren Buffett one of its 17 Climate Killers in 2010, they called him The Profiteer. They zeroed in on his recent purchase of Burlington Northern Santa Fe railroad for $26 billion the largest acquisition of Buffett s sto ried career. Why? BNSF is the nation s top haul er of coal, shipping some 300 million tons a year. That is especially convenient for Buffett because, as noted in Part 2, Berkshire Hathaway Energy has four major utilities that still rely on coal for over half their electricity generation.
But BNSF is so much more than just the top hauler of coal. As their website proudly attests BNSF is the largest transporter of crude oil in North America and we all know how well the whole crude-by-rail thing has been going.
2015 has already been the costliest by far for crude train explosions, BloombergBusiness reported in December. A BNSF train that derailed and exploded in Illinois last March carrying highly explosive crude from North Dakota created some $5.5 million in damage. From 2010 through mid-2014, oil shipped by rail in the United States increased from about one million barrels of oil every month to 25 million! At the same time, Canadian imports increased 50-fold, as we ve reported. BNSF was a driving force behind that explosion.
CREDIT: EIA data
Also, last October we learned about what is believed to be the largest frac sand unit train to date in North America. You guessed it: The 150-car unit train, operated by BNSF, carried 16,500 tons of frac sand used in hydraulic fracturing.
Warren Buffett Bets Big On The Tar Sands
But wait, there s more. You may recall from Part 1 that last year, the billionaire spent $240 million buying another chunk of Canadian tar sands giant Suncor, upping his overall bet on the climate-destroying liquid fuel to $1.1 billion a fact Buffett does not share with shareholders in his list of Berkshire Hathaway s climate risks. On top of that, as BNSF s website also proudly attests, the railroad is positioned to act as a gateway to the Canadian oil sands. Seriously. Indeed several years ago, a BNSF employee magazine explained how invested the railway was in all aspects of tar sands (aka bitumen) development. The key point is that Before bitumen can move through a pipeline to its destination, it must be blended with diluents (diluting agents), lighter weight hydrocarbons like natural gasoline or butane:
BNSF has been moving single carloads of diluents from U.S. refineries to the Canadian border . The inbounds are then interchanged with Canadian railroads, then moved to Edmonton, with the final move to the oil sands processing center via pipeline.
Last year, BNSF moved about 9,000 carloads of diluents for the project, with the majority of loads originating from the Gulf Coast, California, and Kansas. This year, about 12,000 carloads are anticipated to move. There s more: Beyond shipping diluents, BNSF has also transported turbines, other large machinery and pipes for use at the drilling sites. There s still more to this empire. In 2015, Buffett nearly doubled Berkshire s position in Phillips 66, one of the country s leading oil (and gas) refiners and processors. The company has 15 refineries which can refine a total of 2.2 million barrels of crude per day.
In January of this year alone, Buffett spent a staggering $832 million to buy yet more Phillips 66 stock. At more than $5 billion, it his sixth-largest holding. He now owns 14 percent of the Number 7 company on the Fortune 500 list. Phillips 66 is a major co-owner of the Wood River Refinery in Illinois, which in recent years made investments to expand the capacity to handle the bitumen from the Alberta oil sands by nearly 700%. Also not coincidentally, for the last year, Phillips 66 has been trying to get California planning commissioners to let it build a 1.3-mile rail spur to its Santa Maria refinery. Why? As the Sierra Club explained last month, The oil giant seeks to transport tar sands crude from Canada in mile-long trains each laden with over 2 million gallons of dirty crude.
Both A Livable Climate And Buffett s Empire Cannot Thrive
Yes, the Oracle of Omaha has a thing for the Canadian tar sands. But more than that, over the last several years he has built a vertically-integrated fossil fuel empire one that develops, delivers, processes, and even burns the most carbon-intensive fossil fuels. It would be a brilliant strategy except for two small details. First, climate science makes clear we have to leave most fossil fuels and virtually all of the most carbon-intensive in the ground to avoid global catastrophic warming. Second, over the past 18 months, the leading nations of the world unanimously agreed on a plan whose goal is to do just that, and the overwhelming majority of them made detailed pledges to slow or reverse carbon-intensive growth and replace it with carbon-free growth.
The domestic and international coal market has already collapsed as a result of growing environmental concerns and low-cost alternatives including renewables. If the world follows through on its plans to keep total warming below 2 C a big if, for sure then coal is going to continue be squeezed out of the market in the coming decades and oil will almost certainly follow the same fate, peaking in demand by 2030, as I discussed last month. Now whether or not you believe the world is going to achieve the plan it unanimously embraced in Paris in December, surely Buffett ought to at least mention to his shareholders the risks to Berkshire Hathaway if the world does. Yet, his latest annual letter to shareholders dismisses the risk of climate change. Here is all Buffett says about the coal risk: To begin with an obvious threat, BNSF, along with other railroads, is certain to lose significant coal volume over the next decade. But he quickly dismisses this as a problem that is not crucial to Berkshire s long-term well-being.
Last summer, BNSF executive chairman Matthew K. Rose noted the decline in U.S. coal transport and consumption. He said of his company s major investment to upgrade its rail service to and from the coal-rich Powder River Basin, That leaves us with millions of dollars in investment in what will eventually be stranded assets. Certainly, from a short-term business perspective, investing in oil-by-rail and tar-sands-by-rail to replace coal-by-rail appears to make sense. But what are the risks those investments will eventually become stranded assets, too? Low oil prices aren t good for crude-by-rail, as BloombergBusiness explained in December. And aggressive climate action, which could well give us peak demand within 15 years, is not bullish for oil prices.
Rather than informing shareholders about any of these risks, Buffett asserts the reverse: Both BHE [Berkshire Hathaway energy] and BNSF have been leaders in pursuing planet-friendly technology. Seriously? I discussed in Part 2 how, despite BHE s own investments in renewables, BHE is working to crush solar energy in Nevada and around the western United States. And it remains a huge user of coal. And as we ve seen BNSF is a major deliverer of coal .
But here is how Buffett defends the fairly ludicrous claim that BNSF is somehow one of the leaders in pursuing planet-friendly technology :
BNSF, like other Class I railroads, uses only a single gallon of diesel fuel to move a ton of freight almost 500 miles. That makes the railroads four times as fuel-efficient as trucks! Yes, BNSF is a very fuel-efficient way of delivering vast amounts of climate-destroying fuels to market. Finally, is it only a coincidence that after outperforming the market for decades, the stock of Berkshire Hathaway has actually underperformed the S&P 500 over the last five years?
Again, if serious global climate action ultimately keeps oil prices low and renders much of the tar sands uneconomic, then Buffett s carefully constructed fossil fuel empire is going to keep suffering and deservedly so. After all, leading climate activists have been urging major investors to disinvest in fossil fuels for years. Buffett is doing the exact reverse!
BOTTOM LINE: Between Berkshire Hathaway and a livable climate, only one can thrive. That s not a tough choice, is it?
- ^ series (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ Buffett (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ Climate Killers (www.rollingstone.com)
- ^ Part 2 (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ BNSF is the largest transporter of crude oil (www.bnsf.com)
- ^ crude-by-rail (www.bloomberg.com)
- ^ BloombergBusiness reported (www.bloomberg.com)
- ^ shipped (www.eia.gov)
- ^ we ve reported (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ learned about (utu.org)
- ^ Part 1 (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ Berkshire Hathaway s climate risks (www.berkshirehathaway.com)
- ^ proudly attests (www.bnsf.com)
- ^ employee magazine (www.bnsf.com)
- ^ nearly doubled (www.fool.ca)
- ^ has 15 refineries (en.wikipedia.org)
- ^ staggering $832 million (www.reuters.com)
- ^ Number 7 (fortune.com)
- ^ Wood River Refinery (en.wikipedia.org)
- ^ Phillips 66 has been trying (www.sanluisobispo.com)
- ^ explained last month (www.sierraclub.org)
- ^ discussed last month (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ dismisses the risk (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ noted (www.hcn.org)
- ^ explained (www.bloomberg.com)
- ^ peak demand within 15 years (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ Part 2 (thinkprogress.org)
- ^ underperformed the S&P 500 (www.kiplinger.com)
Sure, drones might eventually be part of Amazon s last-mile delivery services but the company has to get pretty serious about fast, long-haul logistics if it wants to continue to offer rapid delivery to growing numbers across the world. Amazon already owns a stake in French freight shipping company Colis Priv , which it s rumored to be outright acquiring soon, and now it s leasing 20 Boeing 767 from a freight aircraft company with a view to buying up to 19 percent of the business over five years.
Interested in tech, huh?
Don t miss our biggest TNW Conference yet!
Join us May 26 & 27 in Amsterdam.
The leases from Air Transport Services Group will last between five and seven years by which time Bezos should have his rockets off the ground, which would make for seriously impressive Amazon deliveries. Or, given that he s already working on taking humans into the sky, perhaps Amazon Flights is next on the cards?
- ^ Amazon s last-mile delivery services (thenextweb.com)
- ^ already owns a stake in French freight shipping company Colis Priv (www.usatoday.com)
- ^ Boeing 767 (en.wikipedia.org)
- ^ Learn more (thenextweb.com)
- ^ Bezos should have his rockets off the ground (thenextweb.com)
- ^ Amazon to lease planes for delivery (www.reuters.com)
- ^ SlashGear (www.slashgear.com)
- ^ Share on Twitter (thenextweb.com)
- ^ Share on Facebook (thenextweb.com)
- ^ Share on LinkedIn (thenextweb.com)
- ^ Email (thenextweb.com)
log. Aguirre acknowledged how the concern associated with Portugal had been an issue connected to doubt within marketplaces in an international degree, nevertheless your woman had long been positive. Although all of us don t get rid of the default, all of us think that this problem within 2015 is genuinely diff.
Special Price: $7.47 Save: 63% off
bal Mug marketing upon Might 10, having a four-day mac cosmetics liquidation bobbi brown blush brush review complement towards their unique Oriental counterparts, in the Wanderers Sports exercises Membership areas within Windhoek. The actual Global Mug will be Worldwide Cricket Council utes (ICC) four-day, first-class competitors for that top Connect along with Affiliate marketer People (AMs). The presentation was performed inside of 2004, nevertheless, this right now assumes using a lot higher importance using any champion within 2017 difficult the very 10th-ranked Complete Fellow member to make the possibility to perform Check cricket. Apart from Hong Kong, Namibia may contend towards Eire, Afghanistan, Papua Brand new Guinea, Scotland, the actual Usa Arabic Emirates (UAE) and also Holland within the two-year cover from search with regards to marketing. Upon Might 15, the actual Namibian Upon Working day Worldwide (ODI) group will stipulate upon Hong Kong within their first ICC Globe Cricket Category Opposition complement. The actual group competent throu.
Special Price: $9.27 Save: 41% off
edward Israel to call home within peacefulness having an self-sufficient Voice regarding Palestine. The particular Us continues that they are extended driving regarding peacefulness among Israelis and even Palestinians. NOT, May possibly several (Xinhua) NOT Secretary-General Exclude Ki- celestial entire body overhead in Wednesday released the session involving Robert Piper involved with Questionnaire because deputy N T p mac makeup suppliers mac 12 eyeshadow palette articular sponsor for the Midst Eastern side tranquility plan of action, to function to your understanding from the two-state option, a new N T spokesman told reporters below Wednesday. Piper s brand-new article is a just how much asst secretary-general, N T spokesman Stephane Dujarric explained along at the day-to-day reports briefing below. Mr. Piper will likely provide when N T kama aina (sponsor coupled with humanitarian sponsor to the Loaded Palestinian Property, inch explained Dujarric. Piper will certainly have great results John Rawley relating to the us. In February. 5, Nickolay Mladenov involving Getaway durante.
Special Price: $8.69 Save: 63% off
ide the main 10 weeks with this season, although enterprise charges became thirty-one. 7 pct coming from recently, mentioned the particular CFLP. The particular CFLP mentioned logistics companies currently have experienced any well-defined drop on the inside income perimeter regarding key establishments, which usually decreased to be capable of 8. 6 pct inside the initial five weeks caused by 15. 6 pct inside the initial a couple of sectors in 2010. BEIJING, 12. 20 (Xinhua) The value involving China s logistics sector journeyed up by 12. 5 per cent year-on-year to 146. 3 trillion yuan (23. apr trillion Oughout. Ersus. dollars) inside 1st 11 a couple of months, explained your Tiongkok Federation involving Logistics coupled with Getting (CFLP) Mondy. The tempo involving expansion features retarded pertaining to a couple of consecutive a few months, along via 13. 3 per cent inside 1st 15 a couple of months, explained your CFLP. Full investing in logistic methods went up by 16. 5 per cent for one to 7. 1 trillion yuan inside same.